Thanks for visiting Capital Advisor. I frequently update this blog to cover various topics on personal finance such as investment strategies, financial products that you should buy and ones that you really should stay away from, financial calculators, emerging themes such as early retirement and financial independence, and much more. You can Subscribe through Email and receive new articles directly in your Inbox or you can Subscribe through the RSS Feed and receive new articles in your feed reader.
I regularly receive emails where readers express their horror stories about LIC’s Jeevan Anand policy. Believing an agent’s (who often happens to be a neighbor/relative/friend) fictional stories of risk and return, they buy the policy only to discover that they need to pay exorbitant premiums for the next 20-years and that when they want to surrender the policy realize that they have a pure yellow lemon in their hand. This realization usually comes after two annual premiums have been paid and the third one is shortly due. So, the question that I am asked to address is should they choose to “pay exorbitant premiums for a few more years and incur a loss” or “pay one more exorbitant premium and incur a loss.”
Here are two sample emails that I recently received.
Please suggest whether I should opt for LIC’s Jeevan Anand policy or not. I am looking for a short-term plan. My agent suggested taking a Jeevan Anand policy for 5-years. I need to pay an annual premium of Rs 24,000 and after the term of 5-years, I will supposedly get Rs 2 lacs (1 lac sum assured plus 1 lac bonus as quoted by the agent).
Does this sound OK or are there any hidden loop holes? Will I get al least Rs 2 lacs after 5-years? Is there any better short-term plan offered by LIC?
I have an LIC Jeevan Anand policy for which I have already paid 2-annual premiums of Rs 25,000 each. In February, I need to pay the third premium. When I purchased the policy, the agent had said that I can close the policy after 3-years. But he never disclosed the fact that even after paying the third premium, I will only get 30% of the last two premiums paid which comes to somewhere around Rs 15,000. If I close the policy now, I won’t get even a rupee back.
I’m not able to understand how you got Rs 50,000 after 6-years. My agent isn’t helping me with any information either. Should I wait for 6-years and get back Rs 50,000 (like you did)? But I don’t want to pay any more premiums after 3-years. Won’t it be better to pay Rs 75,000 in premiums and get back Rs 50,000 after 6-years rather than pay Rs 75,000 in premiums and get back Rs 15,000 after 3-years?
And, way back in May last year, reader Raghuram had asked:
I have been a regular reader of your blog and have learned a lot from you. I have made good investments and have taken proper health insurance and pure term insurance covers for my family. But one mistake I’ve made goes 3-years back when I took an LIC Jeevan Anand policy for 10 lacs cover for 20-years.
After my marriage, because of pressure from a relative (who happened to be an insurance agent), I buckled and bought this policy without reading it or knowing what I was doing. Now I am repenting. I am paying a premium of Rs 42,016 per annum and I have paid 3 premiums so far. The next premium is due in June, 2011.
I went to the local LIC Office and inquired about â€œthe surrender procedure and the surrender amountâ€ that I may get. If I surrender the policy now, I will get around Rs 24,000, which is less than 20% of what I have paid till now. The officer suggested that I hold on to this policy for 2 more years (total 5-years) and then surrender it so that I can get a surrender value of 12.5% of the insured amount (means 12.5% of 1,00,0000 = 1,25,000.)
That means I have to pay another Rs 84,000 and wait for 2 more years to get 1.25 lacs. Here’s what I’m thinking:
Plan #1 — Surrender the policy today
Total Payment = Rs 42,016 x 3 = Rs 1,26,048
Surrender Value = Rs 24,000
Loss = Rs 1,02,000
Plan #2 — Surrender the policy after 2 more years
Total Payment = Rs 42,016 x 5 = Rs 2,10,080
Surrender Value = Rs 1,25,000
Loss = Rs 85,000
Now I need your help. What shall I do? Please let me know your views and thoughts on this and help me out. Waiting to hear back from you.
Here’s what I had replied and this could be a framework to base your decision upon:
I’d cut my losses today.
Think about it this way.
Surrender value of 24,000 today = 28,250 two-years from now @ 8.5% in an FD
1st extra premium of 42,000 today = 49,500 two-years from now @ 8.5% in an FD
2nd extra premium of 42,000 one year from today = 45,600 two-years from now @ 8.5% in an FD
So, at the end of two-years you’ve roughly made 15,350 in interest. More if the interest rate is higher. The notional loss of 17,000 b/w Scenario 1 and Scenario 2 is more or less made up by the interest you earn. Plus, you don’t know what will happen 2-years from today…and the 12.5% return is somewhat suspicious…I didn’t find any such Terms and Conditions in my Jeevan Anand.
What do you say?
Thanks for reading this article. I'd love to hear your opinion. Please use the comments section below to share your thoughts. I frequently write new articles that also cover several other aspects of personal finance including credit cards, financial goals, health insurance, income tax, life insurance, mutual funds, retirement planning, and much more. You can Subscribe through Email and receive new articles directly in your Inbox or you can Subscribe through the RSS Feed and receive new articles in your feed reader.